Login Register

WMN OPINION: Tackling TB epidemic in an issue that cannot wait

By Western Morning News  |  Posted: January 07, 2014

TB
Comments (2)

In a perfect world nobody would want to kill badgers. In that same perfect world there would be no disease. But as we all know real life is just not like that.

Disease, in the form of bovine TB, is ravaging cattle herds across the country but especially here in the South West. The financial costs of the cull – in lost animals and slaughter compensation – runs into millions. The human cost to farmers and their families who may have to have whole herds slaughtered are incalculable.

It took political courage to launch the pilot cull of badgers in Somerset and Gloucestershire. The Conservatives pledged before the last election to take such action and, having come to power – with coalition partners – they kept their promise. Their determination to tackle the problem was welcomed by farmers and supported by this newspaper.

The execution of the cull has been little short of a disaster.

Cull marksmen missed the 70 percent targets in both West Somerset and West Gloucestershire – even after lengthy extensions to the cull period.

Confusion over badger numbers, vagueness around success rates, and a indefensibly feeble communications strategy left many wondering what, if anything, has been achieved. Today we report that the cross-party Environmental, Food and Rural Affairs (Efra) Select Committee of MPs is raising questions over the Government’s plan – highlighting that the failure to accurately calculate badger numbers had “undermined confidence”. There is no doubt that many Tory MPs, traditional supporters of farming and the countryside and allies of farmers, are beginning to lose faith. It is still possible that Environment Secretary Owen Paterson will sanction an extension of the cull in new areas in February or March. If they go ahead, logistical execution will have to be radically improved. But there are increasing numbers of people who think that the free shooting of badgers will never be the answer – and that if the culls have proved anything it is that. There are alternatives. More cage trapping, vaccination, even gassing, and the Government must now find a solution. With the early salvoes already being fired before next year’s general election the danger is that this uncomfortable issue will be parked again behind a wall of science. Bovine TB is an epidemic wreaking havoc in British agriculture. It has to be tackled now.

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters

2 comments

  • barney2  |  January 07 2014, 4:07PM

    I find it hard to except that civilised human beings would consider gassing animals. It is a slow, frightening, painful death. But I guess we are not all 100% human.

    Rate   8
    Report
  • groundnut  |  January 07 2014, 10:48AM

    Paterson and the NFU chose to disregard and bypass expert scientific advice as well as Government financed reports. All of which were clear in their statement, that culling was Not an option to be recommended, or that would bring long term results towards the eradication of BTB. This was not as you have printed any act of Political Courage by Paterson and call me Dave. And still no figures on anything have been released. And Freedom of Information questions to Defra/ Police and Natural England, have provided no answers. Only deliberate avoidance and evasion. It is reported that some £ 7.3 million has been spent on killing Healthy Badgers, because no testing took place of those killed. So under this ideal opportunity to update scientific information or Cage trap and Vaccinate. No action was taken. This amount of money needs some proper explanation to the Taxpayer. It has been squandered by those involved in this killing exercise. When it could have purchased a shed full of Vaccine. Contributed significantly and meaningfully to BTB Scientific Research. Or been used to assist in Farm Bio security improvements. It is no good Paterson and the NFU attempting to place protest and Police costs as the major Factor. They were aware that something as controversial. As well as being unsupported by expert scientific advice would not be condoned by many of the Public. That is now more of the case than at the start, and is added to by the same Minister, again bypassing ecology and its science to propose cutting down Ancient Forests for Development.

    Rate   12
    Report

      YOUR COMMENTS AWAITING MODERATION

       
       

      MORE NEWS HEADLINES

       
       
       

      MOST POPULAR