Login Register

Torquay United's valiant rearguard effort after red card is foiled by late strike

By Western Morning News  |  Posted: December 10, 2012

Referee Darren Bond shows Torquay United's stand-in captain Brian Saah (right) the red card at Bradford City on Saturday afternoon picture: Steve Bond/Pinnacle

Comments (0)

Torquay United may well think that they have a case to make if, after a weekend reviewing video evidence, they decide to appeal against Brian Saah's costly dismissal at Valley Parade.

They will no doubt argue that, yes, Saah raised his arm, but he was trying to take a free-kick awarded his way and he was not even looking at James Meredith when he made contact with the Bradford City defender.

United manager Martin Ling said afterwards that the Gulls may take referee Darren Bond's decision further, for they certainly felt aggrieved at the way this npower League Two match was affected by the 35th minute sending-off of their consistent centre-back and stand-in captain.

With loan signing Angus MacDonald taking over from Saah in the heart of their defence and Michael Poke in top form in goal, United's ten men held out until five minutes from time.

Related content

So it was almost like rubbing salt into the wounds that it should be former Torquay striker Alan Connell who scored the winner, five minutes after rising off the substitutes' bench.

Refereeing his 13th match as a League referee, Mr Bond had kept his red card in his pocket until Saturday, and nothing in the rest of a decent performance from him suggested any knee-jerk reactions.

Nothing much untoward happened in a first half-hour dominated by the Bantams, who are embroiled in a registration row which could see them thrown out of the FA Cup and whose manager Phil Parkinson was able to make eight changes from a midweek Johnstone's Paint Trophy win at Port Vale.

Poke was busy from the start, City's Garry Thompson hooked a chance onto the top of the bar and 14-goal striker Nahki Wells also went close.

Aaron Downes headed a Nathan Craig corner over from close-range but United's main concern was the loss of Billy Bodin, who went down with an ankle knock and was replaced by Niall Thompson in the 27th minute.

Then, eight minutes later, came the big flashpoint. Mr Bond awarded United a free-kick and Saah grabbed the ball to try and get on with the game. Meredith, who was behind Saah, was not the only home player who appeared to attempt to hold things up, and Saah threw out his arm, as much to keep Meredith away as anything else. There did not seem to be any intent to harm.

Linesman Neil Sharp did not flag, but Mr Bond went over to discuss the incident with him. United were getting ready to take the kick when the referee walked back and suddenly produced his red card.

Saah and several team-mates protested, before their stand-in skipper walked away, shaking his head and handing the captain's armband to left-back Kevin Nicholson.

As things stand, Saah will now miss three important matches – Northampton Town at Plainmoor on Saturday and then the two Devon derbies at home to Exeter City on December 22 and away to Plymouth Argyle on Boxing Day.

Ling sacrificed winger Danny Stevens to send on recent loan signing MacDonald at Reading at centre-back.

Almost immediately United nearly snatched the lead. Rene Howe held the ball up in midfield, slipped Thompson through and his right-foot shot on the turn beat home goalkeeper Matt Duke and rebounded off the right-hand post.

It was the nearest that United came to scoring.

City hit the bar through a James Hanson header and Poke saved well from Thompson before half-time. After the interval it was one-way traffic. Ling had reshuffled the formation to 4-3-2, leaving the pacy Thompson up front with Howe to threaten City on the break. But that never happened.

United's defence and midfield had their work cut out just coping with wave after wave of Bradford attacks.

Although Poke had a couple of failures off his line, it did not stop him making several good catches and interceptions under pressure, and his shot-stopping was top-class – Wells would have scored at least a hat-trick without the United goalkeeper's acrobatics.

His best save was a brilliant tip onto his left-hand post and away in the 70th minute.

United resisted with grit, discipline and bravery, eventually forcing Parkinson to go to three at the back and send on Connell ten minutes from time.

The Gulls were just starting to believe that they would hold out when the home pressure told in the 85th minute.

Even more frustratingly, it came from a poor cross by Wells which Craig had a chance to hook clear on the edge of United's area.

A tired swipe at the ball failed to make contact and Connell pounced with a right-foot half-volley which arrowed into the top left-hand corner from 20 yards.

It was certainly a big goal and a big result for Bradford, who moved up to fourth place ahead of tomorrow night's Capital One Cup tie at home to Arsenal.

How costly it proves to be for United, in terms of personnel as well as points, remains to be seen.

Read more from Western Morning News

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters
  • RichmondGull  |  December 10 2012, 2:31PM

    Mr Ling says it was a wonder goal that lost us the match. Rubbish. Look at the stats! Shots on goal: Bradford 31 Torquay 4 Sort of answers itself doesn't it!

  • Vladimpaler  |  December 10 2012, 12:41PM

    It looked to me like he was practising the hokey-cokey ahead of the players Christmas Party

    |   1
  • TimDis  |  December 10 2012, 12:34PM

    All I can say is that Saah gave the ref the opportunity to send him off. It was a bit hot-headed but not malicious. No point in appealing it though.

    |   2
  • Paul_Bradford  |  December 10 2012, 11:27AM

    So, Vladimpaler, can you describe what Saah did with his left elbow, and whereabouts it landed in Meredith's face/neck.............?? Saah's arm was hardly down by his side was it!!!???

    |   -1
  • Vladimpaler  |  December 10 2012, 10:35AM

    I've just seen the footage and it was a ridiculous decision so your comments are not just biased but stupid. His arm did not swing at all so you shouldn't make out it did.

  • Paul_Bradford  |  December 10 2012, 10:22AM

    Hi - I am a Bradford fan and I have to say the comments regarding the red card are incredibly biased. Anyone who has seen the footage cannot condone what Saah did. Meredith did step backwards and stand on Saah's foot - but regardless whether this was intended or accidental, you do not swing your arm back at head height, and if you do then a red card is always a possibility. I understand Saah is mild mannered but he knew what he was doing. If you swing your arm back in a raised fashion, it does not matter whether you are looking or not, you know when your arm is at that height what will happen. I just think your report could do with being a bit more impartial. But good luck for the rest of the season, Torquay have always done better than us in recent seasons and you are rightly proud of your team.

    |   -3