Login Register

Scepticism over Minister's badger pledge

By Western Morning News  |  Posted: December 12, 2012

Comments (0)

It's always nice to hear a Minister delivering a positive message to farmers, but sometimes you have to examine what they are saying in detail.

For example, Farming Minister David Heath told Somerset NFU's annual open meeting: "I promise you it is our very clear intention to do these trials next summer."

Hold it up to the light and all he is doing in reality is promising his listeners the Government intends to do something – not that it will actually be done. There is, you will notice, a world of difference.

And so far as I am concerned it would be better if those trials didn't go ahead, because as currently planned they risk alienating the public even more and diminishing what little respect farmers currently command.

NFU President Peter Kendall may have blustered his membership in accepting the trials with his claim that they represented the only deal on the table. But the only deal isn't necessarily the best deal – and this once certainly isn't. Farmers are going to be painted as the people who shoot healthy badgers.

They are going to be sitting-duck targets for every lunatic who has ever described himself as an animal rights activist. Public opinion will be easily whipped up.

The ground is already being prepared, make no mistake. Was it mere coincidence that a picture of a badger was selected as the front cover for the BBC Countryfile calendar?

I am inclined to think not – and so are the dozens of farmers who have been angered by the use of this image.

The picture, of course, lacks a caption. That should read: "A diseased badger strolls along a quite country lane on his way to infect another cattle herd with TB and drive another hard-working farmer to the brink of suicide."

But no. All the public gets is another pretty picture of an innocent badger with the tacit message that the animal is trotting to an appointment with the marksman's bullet.

The NFU's culling trials represent a very blunt weapon indeed and can only have been championed by an arable farmer with fourth-hand knowledge of the true situation, since arable fields are not exactly wildlife havens themselves.

There are other, more finely-tuned methods of tackling the badger menace. There are techniques available which would result in a targeted cull to remove only those badgers most likely to be diseased – with which the public could hardly argue.

Such an operation will never satisfy the badger-huggers, of course, because they do not accept that any badger, diseased or otherwise, needs to be killed.

But I trust we shall hear no more from their high priest, Brian May, on the subject now that his culling of deer on his estate has been revealed.

Unless, of course, he is able to stand up in public and explain the difference between shooting deer and shooting badgers, particularly when one is a perfectly healthy animal while the other faces a painful, lingering death from the effects of TB.

Derek Mead is an entrepreneur dairy farmer from Weston-super-Mare

Read more from Western Morning News

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters
  • conundrum  |  December 12 2012, 11:15PM

    Surprise, surprise!......And today in the WMN: 2 more 'let's kill the badger' articles for the price of one' This may even be a record for whoever writes this obsessive drivel. Of course, there's nothing much else of great importance going on is there?

    |   2
  • Jude177  |  December 12 2012, 2:24PM

    Article started well and then crumbled into usual incoherence and claptrap!-read the Krebs Report! Get your houses in order farmers and challenge your so called leaders...too right on the public and consumer choice -we have many alternatives-indeed all the publicity is merely highlighting the terrible conditions cattle are kept in and all the down sides to intensive farming -many are already turning to organic farmed produce (and where farms have stated anti-cull) and Welsh produce-a badger cull or more correctly a badger kill (that's what it is as opposed to the Dr Brian May/deer example) would be the nail in the coffin for the english dairy industry-wake up! Jude W

    |   3
  • vulcan  |  December 12 2012, 10:36AM

    Or the 'tacit message' could be, 'there goes a healthy badger about to contract TB from infected cattle'

    |   3