Login Register

Revised pasty tax comes into force

By Western Morning News  |  Posted: October 02, 2012

Comments (0)

Bakeries in the Westcountry were yesterday switching off heater cabinets to help customers avoid paying tax on pasties.

Chancellor George Osborne's "pasty tax" came into force on October 1, but pasty-lovers and retailers would have been hit significantly harder were it not for MPs and the Western Morning News joining forces to persuade the Government into a U-turn.

The Treasury originally announced plans to raise £110 million by levying 20% VAT on hot baked goods at the Budget, a move that would have stung the Westcountry where millions of pasties are made each year.

The move prompted a huge outcry, with critics accusing ministers of waging class warfare against pasty eaters.

Related content

Mr Osborne later staged a climbdown by exempting products that are left to return to "ambient temperatures" on shelves in bakeries and supermarkets.

It means that so long as pasties are not kept artificially warm – via heater cabinets or hot trays – then the dish will avoid the tax, and baked goods sold hot straight from the oven will also be VAT-exempt.

MPs and tax experts argued this was the only realistic compromise to ensure bakeries were distinct from take-away outlets such as fish and chip shops, where VAT at 20% is applied.

The concession was significant, and is estimated to have cost the Treasury around £40 million.

Stephen Gilbert, Liberal Democrat MP for St Austell and Newquay, who led lobbying in Parliament that forced the change of policy, said: "The campaign that the WMN led which was supported by hundred of bakers, and hundreds of thousands of pasty eaters, means that a freshly baked pasty will remain VAT-free.

"This would not have been the case if people had not acted and spoken up. It shows two things – people power works and Government does listen."

But some have voiced concern that food kept warm for customers – such as burger vans, or chestnut stalls – will attract the full tax.

Greg Mayne of accountancy firm Reeves said: "The VAT rise will impact on revenue for already-struggling businesses and may tip some over the brink at a time when many people are cutting back on their discretionary spending, particularly eating out.

"The message to traders, whether they are selling pasties from a shop or hot chestnuts from a stall, is, 'Don't bury your head in the sand' and ignore the VAT."

Read more from Western Morning News

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters
  • The_Real_SKoM  |  October 03 2012, 6:45PM

    Taxman100 In case you missed the debate, the revision allows the distinction between food that is specifically heated up or kept hot for sale and food which has just been cooked and is cooling down. The original for of the legislation had a clause excluding bread for this very reason.

    |   4
  • Taxman100  |  October 03 2012, 11:45AM

    I have never understood the problem with this particular tax. Everyone else selling 'hot' food pays VAT at 20%, so why shouldn't it be added to the sale cost of 'hot' pasties/pies? I don't like paying additional tax any more than anyone else, but surely this tax application is fair and reasonable. What is good for one, is good for another!

    |   -5
  • kernewekonan  |  October 03 2012, 10:37AM

    basically this shower of a coalition have won, not a victory mr gilbert.

    |   2
  • barrtribe  |  October 02 2012, 11:03PM

    ah ok fair enough

    |   1
  • The_Real_SKoM  |  October 02 2012, 10:05PM

    barrtribe. I guess one of you guys must have reported the comment - the administrator will remove reported comments if they also deem them unacceptable.

    |   -6
  • barrtribe  |  October 02 2012, 5:24PM

    weird , where did "truro england" comment go?

    |   -4
  • rozel  |  October 02 2012, 1:31PM

    It seems as if Osborne and Co. are so "cash strapped" that they will go to any lengths to find as many ways of increasing the tax burden that they can without losing too many potential votes. Their next step may well be to impose VAT on all foods, hot cold or otherwise, using the increasing obesity problem as an excuse: one that the wealthy might buy but the poor will reject.

    |   2
  • youngcornwall  |  October 02 2012, 12:29PM

    "MPs and the Western Morning News joining forces to persuade the Government into a U-turn." This doesn't seem to be helping some in the industry by all accounts. http://tinyurl.com/8jh7gzg

    |   -21
  • barrtribe  |  October 02 2012, 12:28PM

    lol i feel a ripple going out throughout the homeland now :)

    |   3
  • Othursty1  |  October 02 2012, 11:14AM

    Hehe. Truro_England, you probably the winner of 'best comment 2012'! But I can also see barrtribe's point - pasties originate from Devon, not Cornwall.

    |   -13