Login Register

Minister's pledge on housing crisis in Devon and Cornwall

By Western Morning News  |  Posted: January 11, 2013

Nick Boles, the Planning Minister, yesterday told the Western Morning News he would deploy "moral pressure" to get critics to accept more house-building

Comments (0)

The minister charged with unleashing a housing boom has admitted going on a "journey" from "Nimby" opponent to building near his family's Westcountry home, to enthusiasm for new development.

Nick Boles, the Planning Minister, yesterday told the Western Morning News he would deploy "moral pressure" to get critics to accept more house-building.

The Conservative MP, who grew up in Devon, said Britain's shortage of affordable homes represented a "crisis in social justice" as he signalled vast swathes of countryside should be offered up to new developments.

Mr Boles recalled his family's unease at proposals to build an estate on the edge of Talaton, near Ottery St Mary, East Devon, next to their home.

But in retrospect, he argues it was a "powerfully good thing for the village" – reviving the local pub and shop and providing houses for young people.

"That journey we all went through as a family," he said. "Now we look out at the estate and it looks like it has always been there."

Mr Boles, MP in rural Lincolnshire, added that the recent 6,300-home Cranbrook settlement in East Devon was the scale of development needed to avert opposition – arguing that new towns would be out of sight of critics and be received more favourably than smaller estates bolted on to villages and small towns.

A house-building boom would also end the growing trend of locals being squeezed out of rural and coastal villages in Cornwall and Devon because of second-home owners. "More land, more house-building – that will be the only long-term fix to this problem," he told the WMN.

Mr Boles yesterday conducted a round of interviews to promote a policy to boost house-building, and warned people had to realise that "either they will spend their retirement propping up their kids and their grandkids, or they can accept more development so their grandkids don't have the problem".

Mr Boles said communities would be offered cash through the Community Infrastructure Levy – which he described as a "bung" – in return for accepting new housing.

He argues just 9% of land in the UK is developed, and increasing the footprint by a fraction would prompt greater house-building. Some 40% of land would remain immune from building through protections including "green-belt" status, he said.

The minister is the son of Sir Jack Boles, the former head of the National Trust and ex-High Sheriff of Devon.

Mr Boles junior said Devon is "one of the most beautiful counties we have" but that young people have housing needs.

While acknowledging the "very controversial" Cranbrook development is not perfect, without the settlement "then you would have to cater to the same need". "You would have to build in every village and every little town," he said. "They are tough choices. They have to be made locally because they are the only places where you can make trade-offs. What we are trying to do is offer an incentive, as well as the moral argument."

He said developments of this size are likely to court less opposition from "Nimbys" – or those who say "Not in my back yard" to building – as the only "people who are going to see it are the ones that are in it. And they'll be happy because they've just bought their first house".

Mr Boles, 47, said his family's unease at building in Talaton close to his grandfather's farm – when he was 12 years old – was a "classic".

"My father and I have talked about it often," he said. "We all have realised that actually that development – while I'm not saying it couldn't have been improved – it was a powerfully good thing for the village.

"It revived the village, it meant it was able to keep a pub going, it meant our community shop has survived and provided housing for young people.

"That journey we all went through as a family. Now we look out at the estate and it looks like it has always been there."

He added that if local planning authorities decided to go ahead with a housing development, those affected had little right to complain.

He said: "I'm afraid there is no in-built right when you buy a house that nothing changes within your immediate vicinity."

Mr Boles, planning minister since September, said the dominance of second homes in desirable parts of the region – in St Minver, near Rock, North Cornwall, more than 42% of homes are owned by part-time residents – is "fixed" by making all houses more affordable.

He said: "You don't hear much of these sorts of problems in Germany, because houses are cheap enough generally that even with pressures from holidaymakers and second home owners, people are able to get on the ladder. More land, more house-building – that will be the only long-term fix to this problem."

Read more from Western Morning News

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters
  • waynejkc69  |  January 11 2013, 12:52PM

    Syrrets, you must obviously be a home owner or have a home that is your assured residence? You speak as if you are. I, on the other hand, am heavily discriminated against and have no ' stable address '. I agree with you that second home owning is a sham and should never be allowed. It is greed in its absolute sense and many MPs are second home owners - even if they rent them out. In the UK we need to start building houses on mass. Rents and mortgages are very high and every ' NIMBY ' forgets that their house was once the product of great debate and NIMBY protesting. Home owners that are NIMBY's seem to forget this FACT. I am surprised at their short-sightedness! Horrified even. On another note, many homes in the UK are owned by foreign rich people that again only use them now and then. This needs to be stopped. A holiday home or second home again is a disgrace and one our MPs welcome by refusing to legislate against. House building is a must. Renovating old houses is also a must. Building rent affordable and mortgage housing is a must. Reducing the influx or migrant workers until the foundations are laid i.e. housing, is a must. And ' No ', I am not a xenophobe, but I do think we opened up our borders before we realized that we had no infrastructure. I think banks and ministers of state - or those with masses of cash - deliberately refuse to build homes because it is more profitable for them. Low housing means higher mortgages, rents and therefore a lifelong guarantee of cash and assets. Even now many parents act as guarantors risking their homes or assets so banks and landlords agree to loan or rent out to their children. This means parents now risk, and often do lose, that which has taken them years to pay for. Ever thought about that NIMBYs? I think not. I have been interested in social welfare for years and I know a lot about the ' housing crises '. I am ashamed to be British and ashamed to have a British Birth Certificate sometimes, this is because I have absolutely no protection from my own Government or their industrial greed: and housing now is an industry. Recently even Ben Bradshaw MP Exeter, my own MP, refused to tell me if he owned any other properties. I find this a scary concept. But it's the society our politicians and their banker and industrial friends have created for cash. Piles of cash!! Roll on the good time….for them. But also, I am ashamed and terrified that my own society members who have their own nests would fight so hard to refuse me my own nest.

  • Syrrets  |  January 11 2013, 11:37AM

    Nick Boles is totally irresponsible to propose a massive house building programme whilst our current housing stock is so poorly utilised and there are so many second-homes in the region (a problem he glibly glosses over with weasel words). Priority should be to renovate and utilise empty houses and reduce (or stop) second-home ownership. More fundamentally, the only viable long-term solution is to stop the unsustainable population growth that the UK is experiencing. Mr. Boles says, "You don't hear much of these sorts of problems in Germany" - well perhaps that is because the population of Germany is falling! The UK is one of the few European countries experiencing significant population growth, yet it is already one of the most densely populated countries (particularly England). Mr Boles claim of "More land, more house-building – that will be the only long-term fix to this problem" could not be further from the truth. This strategy will just lead to more population growth and hence the demand for yet "More land, more house-building", and so on and so on, in a vicious cycle of environmentally destructive development. Yes Mr Boles, provide homes for the current generation, but this MUST be accompanied by measures to stop further population growth in order to stop the problem reoccurring - this is essential if future generations are to have both homes and a decent quality of life in a healthy environment.

    |   8