Login Register

Forestry sector call to end 'in-your-face' spot checks

By Western Morning News  |  Posted: April 13, 2012

Comments (0)

Heavy-handed officials used to dealing with abusive gang masters are being wrongly deployed to target forestry gangs in the Westcountry by turning up clad in stab-proof vests, it is claimed.

Forestry workers say the Gangmaster Licensing Authority (GLA), which was set up to root out exploitation after Chinese cockle pickers were drowned in Morecambe Bay in 2004, is using "Draconian" powers to crack down unfairly on the sector.

They claim the GLA is collecting hundreds of pounds each year in unnecessary fees and prosecuting workers for trivial breaches of laws more applicable to agriculture, shellfish gathering and food processing.

John Wilding, general manager of forestry and environmental economy at Clinton Estates, said the GLA was using "the ultimate sledgehammer to crack a nut".

"They have been very pro-active and in-your-face with forestry squads – using quite Draconian powers and turning up in stab vests," he added.

"There has never been the kind of abuse within the forestry sector that the GLA was brought in to deal with – it just doesn't have that kind of culture of abuse and large contractor teams."

Under GLA rules, small businesses are required to pay an annual licence fee of £400, fill in forms and face inspection.

Breaches such as forgetting to register a change of name or address or delaying the renewal of a licence can carry a fine of up to £1,800.

The trade body Confor, which represents 2,000 forestry and wood-using businesses, is calling on the Government to untie the industry from restrictive red tape which threatens to put jobs at risk.

It wants the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) to heed the recommendation by a taskforce set up to tackle red tape that the sector should be exempt from GLA regulation.

Stuart Goodall, Confor chief executive, said a decision to exempt forestry from GLA control cannot be put off any longer but fears the Government is set to dodge the issue and leave it the Forestry Regulation Task Force.

He added: "The GLA is destroying rural jobs in areas with few other sources of regular employment and placing an unnecessary cost burden on small businesses without any benefits being provided.

"The task force highlighted the low risk nature of the forestry sector and this reflects the GLA's own analysis.

"It is a scandal this has gone on so long already and it is vital that the Red Tape Challenge takes the decision to remove forestry to protect and promote rural employment and the health of England's woodlands."

Defra said no final decision had yet been taken and a change to the GLA regulations "had not been ruled out", adding that there would be an announcement in "a few weeks".

Read more from Western Morning News

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters
  • j_lerner  |  April 13 2012, 5:18PM

    Sir! Whilst whole-heartedly endorsing your point that forestry is a low-risk sector in which the GLA's stab-vested raids have no place I would respectfully question whether this approach is not misplaced across the piece. There is no reported incident of any so-called gangmaster ever attempting to attack a GLA official. Rather, the stab-vests seem to be a vestige of GLA officials' police background which seems inappropriate for the GLA as a whole. Let us not forget that the GLA's first chairman had been dismissed from the police for conducting a media-savvy yet unnecessary armed dawn raid in which his officers killed a naked, unarmed man in bed. He proceeded to staff his organisation almost entirely with dismissed and retired police officers complete with a police press office. Many years on these officials have yet to grasp the fact that they are dealing with businesses, employers and workers, not criminals, and adjust their behaviour to fit in with law-abiding civilised society.

    |   5