Login Register

Devon mum: 'Bedroom tax' has ripped my family apart

By Western Morning News  |  Posted: April 08, 2014

By Sam Blackledge

Valerie Johnson says the Government’s controversial ‘bedroom tax’ has ripped her family apart. Picture: Paul Slater

Valerie Johnson says the Government’s controversial ‘bedroom tax’ has ripped her family apart. Picture: Paul Slater

Comments (6)

A mother from Plymouth who had to move house after the introduction of the controversial “bedroom tax” says the policy has ripped her family apart.

The Government’s divisive measure, introduced a year ago, was designed to crack down on the number of people renting social housing properties with a spare bedroom, by cutting their benefits.

More than 1,000 tenants in Plymouth were hit by the move, and many say they are still feeling the effects 12 months on.

Valerie Johnson, 54, lived in a three-bedroom maisonette run by Plymouth Community Homes with her teenage son Tyler.

Related content

When the bedroom tax was introduced she started losing £11 a week from her housing benefit, which caused a significant shortfall in her finances.

“It was a real struggle,” she says now. “I thought I could cope, but it was awful. At the time my son was going through college and he needed fees paying.

“It was neighbours and friends that were feeding me really. They were wonderful, they never asked for their money back.”

Mrs Johnson was forced to visit food banks and cut down on essential supplies before she was downsized to a two-bedroom flat in West Park in June.

“I was fortunate that they moved me, but I felt as though the choice of moving when I wanted to was taken away from me,” she says. “The Government imposed this on me.

I had to move, and it was a big wrench.”

Mrs Johnson suffers from Myasthenia Gravis, a muscular disease causing fatigue and partial paralysis. Her daughter Lorraine, now 33, used to care for her and would stay over in her spare bedroom three nights a week.

When Lorraine’s living arrangements fell through she wanted to move back home permanently – but Mrs Johnson had already downsized and no longer had a room to spare.

Lorraine could not afford to live in Plymouth so has relocated to St Helens in Merseyside, 280 miles away.

Meanwhile Tyler, 18, is considering whether to go to university or to take a gap year to stay at home and care for his mother.

“It has ripped my family apart,” Mrs Johnson says.

“That is what numbnuts David Cameron has done to us, not just me but thousands of other people.

“He just does not care about the people of the country.

“I can understand down-sizing, it is a good thing in that it allows other people to have places to live.

“But it’s the way he’s doing it. It’s barbaric.”

Mrs Johnson says she is still coming to terms with the lasting impact of the bedroom tax. “It has impacted my health, my finances and worst of all it’s split my family up,” she says. “The knock-on effects on my family are awful. If I’m like that, then thousands of others must be even worse. I’ve seen people like me forced to go to food banks for a tin of beans to feed their kids. It’s heartbreaking.

“One year into bedroom tax if I had one message, it would be ‘Just stop this policy now’.”

Sue Shaw, director of homes and neighbourhoods for Plymouth Community Homes, said: “The residents that we work with every day are strong, resilient people faced with an incredibly tough set of choices. We help enable them to make choices that will make the best of a very difficult situation.

“But our first year of bedroom tax has shown that our residents are suffering the impact very deeply, sometimes having to make a choice between heating or eating. That is not fair on anyone, least of all some of our most vulnerable communities.”

Read more from Western Morning News

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters


  • ElCatski  |  April 10 2014, 4:09PM

    New tenencies,no. people tend to live for decades in their council house. a grace period of 12, maybe 18 months to find somewhere would of been fair. remember, this is not the government kicking people out of their homes, this is the government giving them slightly less free stuff. Here is a litmus test for you. got sky TV? a broadband connection? 20 Lambet & Butler in your pocket? yes? then you are richer than 85% of the worlds population....for doing nothing but being born in the UK.

    Rate   -1
  • Tony248i  |  April 10 2014, 3:47PM

    And seriously, had this "Bedroom Tax" only been applied to new tenancies, one could have made a case for it as being a fair policy. The fact that the Government chose to make it apply to people who were already tenants- and who, in a lot of cases, had no alternative accommodation to move to- is what makes it the wicked thing that it is.

    Rate   3
  • Tony248i  |  April 10 2014, 3:43PM

    If you prefer being a benefit claimant- go for it! No qualifications needed. Will probably even keep you slim as you may not be able to afford regular meals! But I wasn't knocking you, I was knocking "Numbnuts", LOL

    Rate   -4
  • ElCatski  |  April 10 2014, 12:44PM

    yeah, gotta say, being well off is kinda cool. I do prefer it to being poor. You get holidays abroad and wine, all sorts of things. Its great, all you have to do (my little secret) is,look around at the grotty lives of the ghetto care system you are born into, work hard at the free educatuion that the state provides, work hard and long at your first few underpaid jobs for around a decade, mabye a decade and a half, meet a nice girl, enjoy all the little extras in life that you have earned. worked for me. oh, and here's a third of my wages for you to enjoy while im sat in an office all day. cheers.

    Rate   -8
  • Tony248i  |  April 10 2014, 11:01AM

    Most of us would be more than happy to earn enough to be ABLE to pay out £700 a month in taxes. But, yes, you are right, numbnuts does care about the well-off. But no-one else.

    Rate   -2
  • ElCatski  |  April 08 2014, 12:26PM

    "That is what numbnuts David Cameron has done to us, not just me but thousands of other people. "He just does not care about the people of the country." I think he does, I think maybe he cares about us who have to pay your rent, council tax, benefits,childs education,NHS bills,pescriptions. I'm happy to give you £700 a month out of my wages (before i pay my morgage, bills, council tax, fuel for th 160 mile round trip to get to work everyday,all I ask is you spend it wisely.

    Rate   -11